The short answer is above. The first sections below cover what most readers need; tap any later heading to open the detail.
Need help with this? Choosing a tax accountant and understanding fees
Related situations
Rule 11UA valuation defences that hold up
- Before financial year 2023-24, share premium received from a non-resident fell outside section 56(2)(viib) of the 1961 Act.
- Under Rule 11UA(2) of the Income-tax Rules, 1962, the startup could choose Net Asset Value or a SEBI merchant banker's Discounted Cash Flow report (CA DCF reports stopped qualifying in May 2018).
- Notification 81/2023 applies from 25 September 2023 and added five global methods for FY 2023-24 non-resident tranches, a 90-day report validity window, VC price-matching, and a 10% safe harbour.
- High Courts have held that officers cannot swap your chosen method, and in Cinestaan Entertainment the Delhi High Court held that DCF forecasts cannot be rejected using later actuals.
DPIIT recognition and the old Form 2 shield
DPIIT recognition alone did not grant immunity. Under the February 2019 notification (Form 2 text), the company had to file Form 2, keep paid-up capital plus share premium within Rs 25 crore after the issue (shares issued to non-residents, venture capital funds or companies, and specified companies do not count towards that limit), and avoid restricted assets such as non-business land, loans or subsidiary shares for seven years.
Where Form 2 was filed and limited scrutiny raised only section 56(2)(viib) of the 1961 Act, CBDT directed summary acceptance (PIB release), and the 2019 circulars required approval before an officer inquired into a startup that had not filed Form 2.
How to reply without an unexplained-credit addition
- Challenge jurisdiction first if the notice missed the show-cause step (section 148A of the 1961 Act), the outer time limit, or sanction; see reassessment defence and show-cause reply.
- Submit the allotment-date Rule 11UA report, board cash-flow assumptions, and PAS-3 or FC-GPR filings.
- Address unexplained-credit risk under section 68 of the 1961 Act separately with each investor's PAN or residency proof, ITR or net-worth proof, and FIRC or bank statement.
- Protect stay timelines if an order is out (demand stay guide).
Finance Act 2026 also lets you file an updated return after a reopening notice, paying an extra 10% of the tax and interest, which can settle a disputed addition.