Skip to content

Moving to India on a US green card, and both countries call you resident?

We work out the Indian status and the treaty tie-breaker. A US CPA does the US return.

By Founder, TrustNRI. Reviewed by Preetesh Maloo, ICAI-registered Chartered AccountantLast reviewed 14 November 20264 min read

India calls you resident at 182 days, or at 60 days plus 365 in the four years before (section 6). If you are not ordinarily resident, foreign income that both accrues and is received outside India is taxed only when it comes from a business controlled in India or a profession set up in India (section 5). The treats a green card holder as a US resident, taxed on worldwide income (green card test). Where both countries call you resident, Article 4 picks one. A US CPA files the US return.

Confirm this with a practising CA before you act. The answer depends on the year and your documents.

A practising CA at TrustNRI works out your Indian residence, the treaty tie-breaker, and the India return. A US CPA files in the United States. Tell us the month you moved.

Moving to India while the green card is still valid?

Tell us the month you moved and where home and work sit. We will say what India taxes.

Chat on WhatsApp

We use your number to respond to your enquiry. Privacy policy.

Why this happens
You hold a US green card and you have moved to India, or you are about to. India may call you resident on the days. The United States may call you resident because of the card.

The short answer is above. The first sections below cover what most readers need; tap any later heading to open the detail.

Are you resident in India this year

Count 1 April to 31 March. Travel days are on the day-count page.

Your factsThe test in section 6
182 days or more in IndiaResident
60 days this year, and 365 across the four years beforeResident
Citizen or person of Indian origin, only visitingThe 60-day limb does not apply
That visitor, and Indian income other than foreign-source income over ₹15 lakh120 days replaces 60
Indian citizen, not liable to tax in any other country, and that Indian income over ₹15 lakhDeemed resident, whatever the days

Because the US taxes a green card holder on worldwide income, you are usually liable to tax there, so the deemed-resident row normally does not apply. The move year is the split-year page.

The years that are not ordinarily resident

Not ordinarily resident if you were non-resident in nine of the ten preceding tax years, or in India for 729 days or less in the seven before. A visitor who is resident only through the 120-day row (120 to 181 days), and anyone in the deemed-resident row, is not ordinarily resident too. There is no fixed number of years. Use the RNOR calendar.

Salary for work done in India is taxed in India wherever it is paid and whatever your status, unless the treaty's short-stay rule applies ((2): US treaty resident, in India 183 days or less in the year, paid by a non-Indian employer, cost not borne by an Indian establishment) (section 9). Only salary for work done outside India escapes while you are not ordinarily resident. Income accruing outside India is then taxed only from a business controlled in India or a profession set up in India.

When both countries call you resident

Article 4 runs only when both laws already call you resident. It does not change the Indian day count.

  1. Permanent home. A home in both: the closer personal and economic ties.
  2. If that cannot be told, or no permanent home in either: where you habitually live.
  3. Both or neither: your nationality.
  4. National of both, or of neither: the two governments settle it.

If you claim the treaty so the computes US tax as a nonresident alien, file Form 8833. A US CPA does that return. If you have held the green card in 8 of the last 15 years, claiming treaty non-residence can be treated as expatriating for US tax, so raise this with your US tax adviser before you claim.

What you file in India

File on the day-count status. No while you are not ordinarily resident. It starts in the first year you are resident and ordinarily resident. See the foreign-asset page.

Form 44 (formerly ) is the credit in India for foreign tax on income you have offered here. At ₹1 lakh or more, an accountant verifies it. The US return stays with the CPA. Accounts are the account page.

Unsure which form? Ask us on a free call

How we help

  1. 1

    We count the Indian days

    We count the year of the move and say whether you are non-resident, not ordinarily resident, or resident.

  2. 2

    We apply the treaty order

    We apply Article 4 to the homes, work and family you actually have, and leave the US filing with your CPA.

  3. 3

    We set the India return

    We set the status, against that year's instructions, and Form 44 where you claim a credit in India.

Want us to say which papers matter on the call?

Documents you may need

Start with just your phone number. We'll explain which documents are needed on the call.

  • A day-by-day travel list for this tax year and the seven before it
  • Where you have a home, and where your family and work sit
  • The green card, and the name of the US CPA who will file
  • Foreign accounts and salary, and which of that money was paid into India

Common questions

No. India counts days. The green card is what the IRS uses to treat you as a US resident.

Salary for work done in India is taxed in India wherever it is paid. Salary for work done outside India is not taxed in India while you are not ordinarily resident, unless it is received in India.

No. Article 4 sets the order. If those tests do not settle it, the two governments do.

Where the general rule does not apply

Every rule below has a carve-out, a cut-off date or a condition that flips the answer. These are the ones that decide real cases.

Deemed residence: Indian income threshold

Right now: Rs 15 lakh

Where it works differently

The person is liable to tax in any other country
s.6(1A) does not apply at all.
The provision targets stateless-for-tax individuals only.
s.6(1A) applies
The person is RNOR, not ordinarily resident. Foreign income is not taxed in India.
s.6(6)(d).

Commonly got wrong

  • Gulf NRIs earning over Rs 15 lakh in India become fully taxable on worldwide income. They become RNOR, so foreign income remains outside the Indian net.Say 'deemed resident but RNOR, Indian income only'.

RNOR qualification tests

Right now: Non-resident in 9 of the 10 preceding years, OR in India for 729 days or less in the 7 preceding years

Where it works differently

A long-term NRI returns to India permanently
Typically RNOR for two financial years, sometimes three depending on the return date and prior visits.
Both limbs are tested each year; the exact count depends on actual travel history.
The NRI visited India frequently while abroad
RNOR may last only one year, or not apply at all.
The 729-day limb is cumulative across seven years.

Commonly got wrong

  • RNOR always lasts three years. It depends on actual day counts. Two years is the common case; three is not automatic.Say 'usually two years, sometimes three, depending on your travel history', and compute it.
  • RNOR status exempts NRE interest. NRE exemption is tied to FEMA non-residence, which usually ends on permanent return, before RNOR does.Separate the two: RNOR covers foreign income; NRE exemption ends with FEMA residence.

Moving to India while the green card is still valid?

Tell us the month you moved and where home and work sit. We will say what India taxes.

A practising Chartered Accountant handles your Indian tax work.

We use your number to respond to your enquiry. Privacy policy.

Chat on WhatsApp

What to do next

Choose the next step that fits the question you are reading about.