The short answer is above. The first sections below cover what most readers need; tap any later heading to open the detail.
Two countries, two currencies, two different gains
India computes your gain in rupees: the sale price, minus what you paid (plus stamp duty, registration and any improvements), minus transfer costs such as brokerage. As a non-resident you get no indexation for inflation on a sale on or after 23 July 2024. The option to pay 20% with indexation on land or buildings bought before that date is only for resident individuals and HUFs, and a non-resident cannot set the basic exemption limit against this gain either.
The US computes the gain in dollars. Every amount on a US return has to be in US dollars, translated at the exchange rate prevailing when you paid or received it. So your purchase cost is converted at the rate on the day you bought, and the sale price at the rate on the day you sold.
Because the rupee has weakened against the dollar over most long holding periods, the dollar gain is usually smaller than the rupee gain converted at today's rate, and it can even be a loss. India does not care about that: it taxes the rupee gain. A loss on a property you lived in or kept for personal use is not deductible in the US at all, so a currency-driven US loss does not give you anything to offset.
Need help with this? Choosing a tax accountant and understanding fees
Related situations
- Inherited Indian property as a US person: the step-up, the Indian tax and the stranded credit
- Selling Indian property as a US resident, why the Section 54 saving can backfire in the US
- Selling Indian property as an NRI: the rupee-depreciation trap
- The 3.8% NIIT on your Indian gains, interest and rent that Indian tax cannot offset
India side: what the buyer withholds, and how Form 128 cuts it
The tax on a long-term sale (held more than 24 months) is 12.5% of the rupee gain, plus surcharge and 4% health and education cess. Surcharge is 10% where total income is over ₹50 lakh and 15% over ₹1 crore, and on capital gains it never goes above 15%, so the top effective rate is 14.95% of the gain. A short-term sale is taxed at your slab rates.
The withholding is the buyer's job. A buyer paying a non-resident must deduct tax under Section 393(2) of the Income-tax Act 2025, which replaced Section 195 from 1 April 2026. The buyer cannot verify your purchase cost, so without a certificate many buyers take the conservative route and withhold on the whole sale price, at up to 14.95% of it. The law also lets the buyer ask the Assessing Officer to fix the chargeable proportion of the payment (Section 395(2)), but the seller's own certificate is the more common route. Since 1 October 2026 a resident individual or HUF buyer reports this TDS on Form 141 with a new Schedule E for non-resident sellers, using their PAN rather than a separate TAN; other buyers still use a TAN and the non-resident TDS return.
The fix is a lower-deduction certificate under Section 395 (formerly Section 197), applied for on Form 128 (formerly Form 13) on the TRACES portal. You need a PAN to apply, and the certificate is issued in the buyer's name, so it has to reach the buyer before they pay. With it, the buyer withholds roughly the tax on your real gain instead of tax on the full price. Each co-owner applies for their own share.
US side: Schedule D, Form 1116 and why the credit has a ceiling
The sale goes on Form 8949 and Schedule D. Held more than one year, the dollar gain is long-term and taxed at 0%, 15% or 20% federally depending on your taxable income. If you rented the property out, the depreciation you claimed, or could have claimed, reduces your US basis, that part of the gain can be taxed at up to 25%, and the sale may belong on Form 4797 as well as, or instead of, Schedule D. If the flat was your main home for at least two of the five years before the sale (common for people who moved to the US recently), the Section 121 home-sale exclusion of up to $250,000, or $500,000 for a married couple filing jointly, may apply, because the statute has no rule that the home must be in the US.
The India-US treaty lets both countries tax the gain under their own law (Article 13) and requires the US to credit Indian tax subject to US law (Article 25). That credit is claimed on Form 1116, and Section 904 caps it, category by category, at the US tax on your foreign income. A gain on investment property is usually passive category income, but where the Indian tax on it exceeds the highest US rate that could apply, it is treated as high-taxed income and moves to the general category. For a gain taxed at the 15% rate, the cap works out to roughly 15% of the dollar gain. Indian tax above the cap is carried back one year and forward ten, but it can only be used against US tax on foreign income in the same category, which many people do not have.
Three more limits matter. The credit is computed against regular income tax, which excludes the 3.8% Net Investment Income Tax, so NIIT on the gain (where your modified AGI is over $200,000 single or $250,000 married filing jointly) gets no credit. TDS that was over-withheld and is refundable in India is not a creditable tax: you have to claim it back from India, and if a refund arrives after you claimed the credit, the IRS must be told: usually by an amended return, or on Schedule C (Form 1116) where the change does not alter your US tax. And most states do not credit foreign tax; California, for example, taxes capital gains as ordinary income and allows no foreign tax credit.
The timing mismatch: Indian tax year versus US calendar year
India's tax year runs 1 April to 31 March; the US year is the calendar year. A sale in November 2026 falls in the US 2026 return, due 15 April 2027, but in India's 2026-27 tax year, which closes on 31 March 2027, and the Indian return is filed after that. So when your CPA starts the US return, the Indian tax may not be final.
Two IRS rules govern this. Tax withheld in rupees is converted to dollars at the exchange rate on the date it was withheld. And a cash-basis taxpayer can elect, on a timely original return, to claim foreign taxes in the year they accrue; Indian tax accrues on the last day of the Indian tax year. If your US return is ready before the Indian figure is settled, a filing extension (to 15 October) buys time to file, though not to pay.
This is why a Form 128 certificate helps on both sides: when the TDS is close to the real Indian tax, the number your CPA credits in 2026 is close to the final number, and there is no large Indian refund that later has to be reported back to the IRS.
A worked example: Priya in California sells a Bengaluru flat
Priya is a US citizen living in California, filing jointly. She bought a Bengaluru flat in 2013 for ₹55,00,000 and sells it in November 2026 for ₹1,32,00,000. Exchange rates here are illustrative round numbers: ₹55 per dollar when she bought, ₹88 when she sells. For simplicity, transfer costs are ignored and the Indian tax is withheld at sale.
India side (rupees)
| Step | Working | Amount |
|---|---|---|
| Long-term gain | ₹1,32,00,000 minus ₹55,00,000 | ₹77,00,000 |
| Tax at 12.5% | ₹77,00,000 x 12.5% | ₹9,62,500 |
| Surcharge at 10% (income over ₹50 lakh, under ₹1 crore) | ₹9,62,500 x 10% | ₹96,250 |
| Cess at 4% | ₹10,58,750 x 4% | ₹42,350 |
| Indian tax | ₹11,01,100 | |
| TDS with no certificate (14.95% of the price, since the payment exceeds ₹1 crore) | ₹1,32,00,000 x 14.95% | ₹19,73,400 |
| Over-withheld, waiting for an Indian refund | ₹19,73,400 minus ₹11,01,100 | ₹8,72,300 |
US side (dollars)
| Step | Working | Amount |
|---|---|---|
| Cost basis | ₹55,00,000 / 55 | $100,000 |
| Amount realised | ₹1,32,00,000 / 88 | $150,000 |
| US long-term gain | $150,000 minus $100,000 | $50,000 |
| Same gain measured India's way, at today's rate | ₹77,00,000 / 88 | $87,500 |
| Federal tax at 15% | $50,000 x 15% | $7,500 |
| Indian tax in dollars (withheld at ₹88) | ₹11,01,100 / 88 | $12,513 |
| Credit allowed (capped at the US tax on the gain, simplified) | lower of $12,513 and $7,500 | $7,500 |
| Federal income tax left on the sale | $7,500 minus $7,500 | $0 |
| Unused Indian tax carried back 1 / forward 10 years | $12,513 minus $7,500 | $5,013 |
| California tax, no credit for Indian tax (at a 9.3% bracket) | $50,000 x 9.3% | $4,650 |
| NIIT: 3.8% of the lower of the gain and joint MAGI above $250,000; full amount only if MAGI is $300,000 or more | $50,000 x 3.8% | up to $1,900 |
The rupee fell from 55 to 88, so a ₹77 lakh gain in India is only a $50,000 gain in the US. India's tax of about $12,500 is more than the federal tax it can offset, so about $5,000 of credit is carried forward and California's tax is paid on top. Without the Form 128 certificate, a further ₹8.7 lakh would also sit with the Indian tax department until her Indian return is processed, and only the final ₹11.0 lakh is creditable in the US anyway.
Getting the money to the US
Sale proceeds land in your NRO account. RBI's Master Direction on Remittance of Assets lets an NRI or person of Indian origin remit up to USD 1 million per financial year (April to March) from NRO balances, sale proceeds of assets and inherited assets, on documentary evidence and after applicable Indian tax; more than that needs RBI approval.
For the bank, Form 145 (formerly 15CA) is filed before each remittance, and which part applies depends on the facts. Where the remittance is taxable and the year's total is over ₹5 lakh, Part B applies if an Assessing Officer's certificate has been obtained; otherwise Part C, which needs a chartered accountant's certificate on Form 146 (formerly 15CB). Payments not chargeable to tax follow a different part. Once the money is in the US, keep in mind that an NRO balance over $10,000 at any point in the year (counting all your foreign accounts together) is reportable on the FBAR.
If you inherited the property rather than bought it, the US cost basis works very differently and the credit problem is usually worse. That case has its own page: inherited Indian property and the US step-up.