Skip to content
Back to all posts
section-119-2bpast-year-recoverycondonationdtaa-recovery

Section 119(2)(b) gives NRIs 5 Assessment Years to claim back excess TDS. Most never use it.

TL;DR

If you're an NRI and your Indian bank deducted 30% TDS instead of your DTAA treaty rate, Section 119(2)(b) lets you recover the excess for up to 5 past Assessment Years (CBDT Circular 11/2024). Principal only on a Section 119(2)(b) condoned claim; no Section 244A interest (Circular 11/2024). Most NRIs don't know this exists. Here's the full mechanism.

Need help applying this to your situation?

Start with a free 15-minute CA call. Your number is enough; no documents needed yet.

Chat on WhatsApp

We use your number to respond to your enquiry. Privacy policy.

By , Founder

Reviewed by Preetesh Maloo, Chartered Accountant, NRI Tax Partner

Published 2026-04-28 11 min read ICAI-registered CAs

The 5-AY window most NRIs don't know

Most s assume that once a financial year closes and the deadline passes, the chance to claim a refund is gone. That's not how Indian tax law works for NRI cases. of the Income-tax Act explicitly lets NRIs file revised returns for up to 5 past Assessment Years ( Circular 11/2024) and claim back excess that should have been at the treaty rate.


The legal hook: of the Income-tax Act 1961, plus the relevant circulars on , gives the assessing officer (or higher CBDT authorities for larger amounts) the power to condone delays in claim filing where there's a genuine hardship.


For s, 'genuine hardship' usually translates to: you didn't know about , your bank deducted 30% under default, you didn't have + on file, and you've now realised the gap. has been broadly accepting on this for non-willful cases.


The rolling 5-AY window ( Circular 11/2024) means every April, the oldest year drops out. So a Singapore filing a fresh in April 2026 can reach back to FY 2020-21 (AY 2021-22) under the 5-year-from-end-of-AY rule.

Want a senior CA to handle this for you, start to finish?

Free 15-minute call. We tell you what applies to your case, and what it takes.

A practising Chartered Accountant handles your Indian tax work.

We use your number to respond to your enquiry. Privacy policy.

Chat on WhatsApp

What Section 119(2)(b) actually does

is a discretionary power. The , acting through the Pr.CIT or CIT for claims up to ₹1 crore, can:


Condone the delay in filing a claim or revised return.

Accept the late claim as if filed within time.

Process the refund, as principal only (no interest on a condoned claim under Circular 11/2024).


What it doesn't do:

It isn't an automatic right. The must actually issue the order before the processes the revised return.

It doesn't waive Section 271 penalties for genuinely concealed income.

It doesn't extend statute-of-limitations for new assessments by the IT Department against you.


For recovery specifically, is paired with (now transitioning to from April 2026) and a from your country. You file:

A application to the .

A revised -2 for each year being claimed.

The + for the year.

A computation showing the treaty-rate vs default-rate gap.


Approval typically takes 4 to 8 months per year claimed. Refunds then process under within 6 to 12 weeks of approval.

The CBDT order: monetary thresholds and routing

Circular 11/2024 sets monetary limits per assessment year, and they decide who signs the :


Up to ₹1 crore for the assessment year: Pr.CIT or CIT (Principal Commissioner or Commissioner of Income Tax).

Above ₹1 crore and up to ₹3 crore: Pr.CCIT or CCIT (Principal Chief Commissioner or Chief Commissioner of Income Tax).

Above ₹3 crore: .


For most s, the refund for any one assessment year sits well below ₹1 crore, so the local Pr.CIT or CIT decides. That is faster than central routing.


The limit is tested year by year, so a larger five-year total does not move you up a tier, and splitting a claim into smaller applications changes nothing. Your CA prepares one clean pack with a year-wise computation.

Step-by-step: filing a Section 119(2)(b) condonation

The full workflow takes 8 to 12 weeks of preparation, then 4 to 8 months for approval.


Week 1 to 2: Gather documents. for each FY being claimed. (or for FY 2026-27 onward) for each year. / for each year showing actual deducted. Bank statements showing the income. Proof of status for each year (passport stamps, employer letters, foreign bank statements).


Week 3 to 4: Compute the recoverable amount. For each year: gross income times default rate equals actually deducted. For each year: gross income times treaty rate equals TDS that should have been deducted. Gap equals recoverable per year. Sum across years.


Week 5 to 6: Draft the application. Cover letter explaining genuine hardship. List of years and amounts. Statement of facts. Certified s. Draft revised for each year.


Week 7 to 12: File the application with the PCIT and the revised s on incometax.gov.in.


Months 4 to 8 post-filing: PCIT reviews. Often asks one round of clarifications. Approval order issues. processes the returns. Refund credits as principal, without interest.

Section 244A: the monthly interest you will NOT get on a condoned claim

of the Income-tax Act says: when the IT Department delays a refund of , TCS or advance tax, they pay simple interest at 0.5% for every month or part of a month. On an in-time return that runs from 1 April of the assessment year to the date the refund credits; on a late return, from the filing date.


There is a large exception, and it is exactly the case most s are in. Circular 11/2024 makes it a condition of that no interest is admissible on a belated refund claim. So a past year recovered under , which is the route for anything older than the current assessment year, returns the over-withheld principal and nothing on top.


Where 244A does run is a refund on a return filed in time: interest from 1 April of the assessment year, or from the filing date if the return was belated, to the date the refund credits. It is computed by the on the refund order without you asking, and it is taxable in the year you receive it.


So when you are budgeting a five-year recovery, budget the principal. Treat any interest as the exception rather than the plan, and be wary of anyone quoting you an interest figure alongside a .

The math on a typical 5-AY recovery

A Dubai-based with a ₹40 lakh at 7% over 6 financial years (FY 2020-21 through FY 2025-26):


Gross interest each year: ₹2.8 lakh.

Default at 30%: ₹84,000 each year.

Treaty at 12.5%: ₹35,000 each year.

Gap each year: ₹49,000.

FY 2020-21 to FY 2024-25 (AY 2021-22 to AY 2025-26) go through . Gap across those 5 Assessment Years: ₹2.45 lakh, returned as principal only, because Circular 11/2024 allows no interest on a belated refund claim.


FY 2025-26 (AY 2026-27) needs no if its return is filed by the deadline (a belated return is allowed until 31 December 2026). Its ₹49,000 refund can carry interest.


Grand total recoverable: about ₹2.94 lakh of principal, plus a small amount on the FY 2025-26 refund only.


The example above shows the tax calculation before professional fees. Any work is separately scoped, with a fixed fee agreed in writing before it starts; the fee is never a share of the recovery.

Why your CA didn't tell you

Most CAs charge a flat fee per . is significantly more work than a regular ITR: drafting the cover letter, gathering 5 Assessment Years of s, computing year-by-year gaps, following up with the PCIT. Maybe 12-18 hours of work for an extra ₹5,000-15,000 of revenue.


The math doesn't favour the CA at flat-fee pricing. Hours-of-work-per-rupee-of-revenue is much worse than a fresh .


Leave just your phone or WhatsApp number for a free 15-minute call. We'll explain the proposed scope and quote a fixed fee in writing before any paid work. Our fee is fixed, never a share of your refund. You decide whether to proceed; no documents are needed for the first call.


A quote should make clear what work is included and which tasks, if any, would need a separate agreement.


Trust starts with a free call so you can understand the proposed work and fee before deciding.

What we actually do

Leave just your phone or WhatsApp number for a free 15-minute call. We'll explain the proposed scope and quote a fixed fee in writing before any paid work. Our fee is fixed, never a share of your refund. You decide whether to proceed; no documents are needed for the first call.


Indian-side scope: liaison with the foreign authority for each year, / refile (or Form 41 for FY 2026-27 onward), revised -2 drafting, petition under , correspondence under , and 26AS reconciliation across all 5 Assessment Years.


The Pr.CIT or CIT decides claims up to ₹1 crore per assessment year; above that the application goes to the Pr.CCIT or CCIT (up to ₹3 crore) or the (above ₹3 crore).


If you have s, dividends, or rental income with potentially over-deducted in the past 5 Assessment Years, upload your 26AS at /ais-analyzer for a free recovery estimate. We quote the recoverable amount within 24 hours; you decide whether to engage. If you'd rather Book free CA appointment first to discuss the strategy, that's free, no card, no commitment, 15 minutes.

Frequently asked questions

Q: I haven't been an for the full 5 Assessment Years. Can I still claim for the years I was?

A: Yes. applies year-by-year based on your status that year. If you were an for FY 2020-21 to FY 2024-25 but resident for FY 2019-20, you claim only the 5 NRI years.


Q: I never filed an for those past years. Can I still file under ?

A: Yes. The specifically allows filing belated or revised returns for years where you didn't file or filed without claiming . The application makes the case for genuine hardship.


Q: What's the acceptance rate?

A: For non-willful cases with documentary support (, , bank records), our success rate over 4 years has been roughly 88%. The remaining 12% are typically rejections for incomplete documentation or willful concealment indicators.


Q: Can I claim on my own without a CA?

A: Technically yes. Practically, the application requires drafting in legal-standard format, computational worksheets, and follow-up with the PCIT office. Most s without tax-law experience underweight the application's importance and end up with a rejection that's hard to reverse. Ask the CA to explain the scope and agree a fixed fee in writing before work starts. The fee is fixed, never a share of the refund.


Q: How long does the full process take?

A: 8-12 weeks of preparation (mostly waiting on s from foreign authorities) plus 4-8 months for PCIT approval per submission. So roughly 6-10 months end-to-end. No interest is paid on a refund allowed through ( Circular 11/2024), so the wait is not compensated.

Still have a question?

Ask our AI anything about this. It answers from our guides in plain English, and a CA takes over for your exact case.

AI guidance, not advice. Verify your exact case with a CA.

Talk to a CA

What to do next

Choose the next step that fits the question you are reading about.

Get weekly DTAA insights for UAE NRIs

Tax tips, treaty updates, recovery strategies. No spam. Unsubscribe anytime.

Join 2,000+ Indians in Dubai who get our weekly digest.