The short answer is above. The first sections below cover what most readers need; tap any later heading to open the detail.
Step one: map your RNOR window to the day
Everything else hangs on your residential status, year by year. India's tax year runs 1 April to 31 March.
Resident at all? You are resident in a year if you are in India for 182 days or more (other tests exist but returnees usually meet this one).
RNOR or ROR? Under Section 6(6) of the 1961 Act, carried into Section 6(13) of the 2025 Act, a resident individual is 'not ordinarily resident' if either test holds: (a) non-resident in 9 out of the 10 preceding years, or (b) 729 days or less in India across the 7 preceding years. Failing both makes you Resident and Ordinarily Resident (ROR).
Why it matters. An RNOR is not taxed on income that accrues outside India unless it is received in India or comes from a business controlled or profession set up in India (Section 5(1) proviso). The test is where the income is first received: a withdrawal paid into your US account is received abroad, and transferring that money to India later is a remittance of money already received, not new income. A withdrawal paid straight into an Indian account is received in India. Rule 74 itself confirms that income from a US retirement account that was not taxable because you were non-resident or RNOR is kept out of the Section 89A computation for good.
Worked count. Anand lands in Bengaluru on 15 June 2026 after twelve years in the US, having visited India about 25 days a year.
| Tax year | Days in India | Test (a): NR in 9 of 10 before? | Test (b): days in 7 before | Status |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| 2026-27 | 290 (15 Jun to 31 Mar) | Yes, 10 of 10 | under 729 | RNOR |
| 2027-28 | 366 | Yes, 9 of 10 | 150 + 290 = 440 | RNOR |
| 2028-29 | 365 | No, 8 of 10 | 125 + 290 + 366 = 781 | ROR |
So Anand has two RNOR years, 1 April 2026 to 31 March 2028. Had his visits totalled 73 days or fewer over the five earlier years, test (b) would have held for 2028-29 and he would have had a third.
What Section 89A (now Section 158) actually does
Once you are ROR, India taxes residents on worldwide income, and the conservative reading is that dividends, interest and gains arising inside a 401(k) or IRA are your income as they accrue. The US taxes nothing until you withdraw. India's tax arrives first; the US tax arrives years later; and a foreign tax credit is given only in the year the income is offered to tax in India. The two never meet.
Section 89A fixes the timing, not the amount. Read with Rule 21AAA (Rule 74 from tax year 2026-27):
| Condition or effect | What the rule says |
|---|---|
| Who qualifies | A 'specified person': a resident of India who opened the account while non-resident in India and resident in the notified country |
| Which countries | Notified countries only. Notification 25/2022 (4 April 2022) names Canada, the UK and the USA |
| Which accounts | An account in that country taxed there on withdrawal or redemption, not on accrual |
| What moves | Income accrued in the account is taxed in India in the year the US taxes the withdrawal |
| What is excluded | Income already taxed in India, and income not taxable when it accrued because you were non-resident or RNOR or because of the treaty. Foreign tax on that excluded income is ignored for the credit |
| Scope | The option covers all your specified accounts; you cannot pick one 401(k) and leave an IRA out |
| How and when | Form 10-EE (Form 40 from tax year 2026-27), filed electronically on or before the return due date for that year |
| Lock-in | Applies to all later years and cannot be withdrawn |
| If you leave India | If you become non-resident again, the option is deemed never exercised from that year, and income accrued since the election becomes taxable in the year before you became non-resident, with tax due by that later year's return due date |
Roth accounts. A qualified Roth IRA withdrawal is not taxed by the US, so a Roth does not obviously meet the 'taxed on withdrawal' condition, and no CBDT clarification settles it. Treat a Roth as outside the election unless your CA has a reasoned basis.
The US side: penalty, withholding and the treaty pension article
10% additional tax. Under IRC Section 72(t), distributions before age 59 and a half generally attract a 10% additional tax on top of income tax. One exception matters to returnees: for a 401(k) (not an IRA), separating from that employer in or after the year you turn 55 removes it. Rolling a 401(k) into an IRA forfeits that exception.
Which kind of taxpayer you are. If you are a US citizen or still a green-card holder, the US taxes you on worldwide income regardless of where you live; the treaty's saving clause (Article 1(3)) preserves that, and the pension article does not override it. If you are an Indian citizen who has given up US residence, you are a nonresident alien and the treaty matters.
The treaty pension article. Article 20(1) of the India-US treaty says a private pension or annuity paid from the US to a resident of India may be taxed only in India. But Article 20(3) defines a pension as a periodic payment for past services. A lump-sum 401(k) or IRA cash-out is generally not periodic, and income not covered by another article that arises in the US may also be taxed in the US under Article 23(3).
Withholding. Publication 515 says a plan must withhold 30% on a US-source pension distribution to a foreign person unless a treaty exemption is documented; the payer may instead apply graduated rates to the part that arises from US services after 1986. The final US tax is settled on the nonresident return, and it is your US advisor's call.
Required minimum distributions. The US requires minimum annual withdrawals from a traditional IRA from the 'applicable age': 73 if you reach 72 after 2022 and 73 before 2033, and 75 if you reach 74 after 2032 (IRC 401(a)(9)(C)(v)), the first by 1 April of the following year. For anyone born in 1960 or later that is 75. Roth IRA owners have no lifetime RMDs.
A worked example: the same 401(k), two timings
Anand (born October 1971) holds a $400,000 401(k), all pre-tax, opened while he was a US resident and non-resident in India, so he is a specified person. He gave up his green card and left his US employer in May 2026, aged 54 but in the calendar year he turns 55. All dollar figures and growth rates are illustrative; the rules applied are real.
Timing A: withdraw $100,000 in December 2027, inside the RNOR window. India: the income accrued outside India and is paid into his US account while he is RNOR, so India taxes nothing. US: he is 56, but he separated from service in 2026, the year he turns 55, so the age-55 exception applies to a distribution from that employer's 401(k): 10% additional tax = $0. (Had he rolled the money into an IRA first, the exception would be lost and the additional tax would be 10% x $100,000 = $10,000.) US income tax on the distribution still applies. The plan withholds 30% = $30,000 by default unless documentation supports a lower amount, and the final figure is settled on his US return.
Timing B: keep the account until after 59 and a half, elect Section 158. He becomes ROR on 1 April 2028 with the account at $460,000. It grows by $20,000 a year and he withdraws everything, $520,000, in May 2031 (tax year 2031-32), after turning 59 and a half in April 2031, so no 10% additional tax.
| Without the election | With Form 40 filed | |
|---|---|---|
| India taxes | $20,000 accrual in each of 2028-29, 2029-30, 2030-31 | $60,000 in 2031-32, the withdrawal year ($520,000 minus $460,000) |
| Indian tax at a 30% marginal rate | On the conservative accrual reading, $6,000 a year, before any US tax exists | $18,000, in 2031-32 |
| US tax (assume 24% of the distribution) | $124,800 in 2031 | $124,800 in 2031 |
| US tax attributable to the India-taxed slice | Arrives years after the Indian tax, so matching a credit is uncertain | $124,800 x 60,000 / 520,000 = $14,400 |
| Indian credit (lower of Indian tax and foreign tax on that income, Rule 76) | Not established | $14,400 |
| Net Indian tax | Up to $18,000 | $18,000 minus $14,400 = $3,600 |
The $20,000 of yearly growth after 1 April 2028 is accrued income India can tax; the election moves it to the withdrawal year, where the US tax on the same slice can be credited. Because the option is exercised, Rule 74(2)(b) keeps the accrual from his non-resident and RNOR years out of the computation (only the $60,000 is included), and the US tax on that excluded part is ignored for the credit. We do not compute the without-election column beyond the conservative accrual reading, because how India would treat the withdrawal year without the option is not settled. The 30% figure is India's top new-regime slab (income above Rs 24 lakh); surcharge and cess, which depend on total income, are left out to keep the arithmetic readable.
A dated decision timeline (Anand's dates; yours shift with your return date)
| Date | Decision point | Rule |
|---|---|---|
| Before leaving the US (May 2026) | Note your separation year: the age-55 exception applies to the 401(k) of an employer you leave in or after the calendar year you turn 55 (Anand turns 55 in October 2026, so it applies), and is lost if the money is rolled into an IRA | IRC 72(t) |
| 15 June 2026 | Arrival; 290 days in India in tax year 2026-27, so resident; RNOR under the 9-of-10 test | Section 6 |
| 1 Apr 2026 to 31 Mar 2028 | RNOR window. Growth and any withdrawal first received outside India are outside Indian tax. A later transfer of money already received abroad is not new income; a withdrawal paid directly into an Indian account is received in India and is taxable | Section 5(1) proviso; Rule 74(2)(b) |
| 31 Jul 2027 and 31 Jul 2028 | Indian returns for the two RNOR years (due date for individuals without business income) | Section 263(1)(c) |
| 1 Apr 2028 | ROR begins; the account enters the Indian net and Schedule FA disclosure | Section 6 |
| On or before 31 Jul 2029 | Last date to file Form 40 for tax year 2028-29, the first ROR year, so that no year is taxed on accrual. Lock-in from then on | Rule 74(3) and (5) |
| April 2031 | Age 59 and a half; the 10% additional tax no longer applies | IRC 72(t) |
| May 2031 | Withdrawal; US tax withheld; India taxes the post-RNOR accrual in tax year 2031-32 | Rule 74(1) |
| By 31 Mar 2033 | Form 44 for the foreign tax credit, within twelve months of the end of tax year 2031-32, CA-verified because the foreign tax is above Rs 1 lakh | Rule 76(12), (16) |
| Age 75 (October 2046) | Applicable age for someone reaching 74 after 2032; traditional IRA required minimum distributions begin, the first by 1 April 2047 | IRC 401(a)(9)(C)(v) |
If you might leave India again, weigh Rule 74(4) before filing: becoming non-resident unwinds the election and pulls the deferred income into the preceding year.