Skip to content

Returning to India with a 401(k) or IRA: the RNOR window, Section 89A, US withdrawal tax and a dated plan

You are moving back, or already back, and the 401(k) or IRA is still in the US. You want to know when India taxes it, when the US does, and what has to be filed by when.

By Founder, TrustNRI. Reviewed by Preetesh Maloo, ICAI-registered Chartered AccountantLast reviewed 18 October 202613 min read

In your RNOR years, income that accrues outside India is not taxed in India unless it is received in India, so 401(k) growth and withdrawals first received in a US account are outside Indian tax. Moving money already received abroad to India later does not by itself create taxable income. Most returnees get two or three RNOR years: you qualify if you were non-resident in 9 of the 10 previous years, or spent 729 days or less in India in the previous 7. Once you are Resident and Ordinarily Resident, the account is in the Indian net. Section 89A (Section 158 from tax year 2026-27) lets a 'specified person', someone who opened the account while non-resident in India and resident in the US, elect to have India tax the account's income in the year the US taxes the withdrawal. The election is Form 10-EE (Form 40 from tax year 2026-27, under Rule 74), filed on or before the return due date. It covers all your specified accounts, applies to every later year, and cannot be withdrawn. Income that accrued while you were non-resident or RNOR is excluded. On the US side, withdrawals before 59 and a half generally carry a 10% additional tax. For a non-US citizen who is an Indian resident, the India-US treaty gives India the sole right to tax a periodic pension, but a lump sum is generally outside that article, and plans withhold 30% by default from payments to foreign persons without treaty documentation. India then credits the US tax on the same income on Form 44 (formerly Form 67).

Returning to India with a 401(k) or IRA?

Start with a free 15-minute scoping call. We’ll identify what needs reviewing and quote for the India-side work: your residency position, retirement-account treatment and any relevant election or filing. US tax advice stays with your US adviser.

Chat on WhatsApp

We use your number to respond to your enquiry. Privacy policy.

Start with a free 15-minute scoping call. We’ll identify what needs reviewing and quote for the India-side work: your residency position, retirement-account treatment and any relevant election or filing. US tax advice stays with your US adviser.

No account statements needed to request the call. Any filing is scoped and agreed separately after reviewing your circumstances.

Why this happens
You built up a 401(k) or traditional IRA over years in the US and have moved back to India. Two tax systems now look at the same money on different clocks. The US taxes the account when you withdraw, and adds a 10% additional tax if you are under 59 and a half. India, once you are Resident and Ordinarily Resident, can on the conservative reading tax the growth inside the account as it accrues, years before any US tax exists to credit against it. India's answer is Section 89A of the 1961 Act, now Section 158 of the Income-tax Act 2025: an election that moves the Indian tax to the year the US taxes the withdrawal. Before that, there is usually a better tool, the two or three years as Resident but Not Ordinarily Resident (RNOR), when foreign income is outside the Indian net entirely. The order in which you use these, and the deadlines attached, decide how much of the account is taxed twice.

The short answer is above. The first sections below cover what most readers need; tap any later heading to open the detail.

Step one: map your RNOR window to the day

Everything else hangs on your residential status, year by year. India's tax year runs 1 April to 31 March.

Resident at all? You are resident in a year if you are in India for 182 days or more (other tests exist but returnees usually meet this one).

RNOR or ROR? Under Section 6(6) of the 1961 Act, carried into Section 6(13) of the 2025 Act, a resident individual is 'not ordinarily resident' if either test holds: (a) non-resident in 9 out of the 10 preceding years, or (b) 729 days or less in India across the 7 preceding years. Failing both makes you Resident and Ordinarily Resident (ROR).

Why it matters. An RNOR is not taxed on income that accrues outside India unless it is received in India or comes from a business controlled or profession set up in India (Section 5(1) proviso). The test is where the income is first received: a withdrawal paid into your US account is received abroad, and transferring that money to India later is a remittance of money already received, not new income. A withdrawal paid straight into an Indian account is received in India. Rule 74 itself confirms that income from a US retirement account that was not taxable because you were non-resident or RNOR is kept out of the Section 89A computation for good.

Worked count. Anand lands in Bengaluru on 15 June 2026 after twelve years in the US, having visited India about 25 days a year.

Tax yearDays in IndiaTest (a): NR in 9 of 10 before?Test (b): days in 7 beforeStatus
2026-27290 (15 Jun to 31 Mar)Yes, 10 of 10under 729RNOR
2027-28366Yes, 9 of 10150 + 290 = 440RNOR
2028-29365No, 8 of 10125 + 290 + 366 = 781ROR

So Anand has two RNOR years, 1 April 2026 to 31 March 2028. Had his visits totalled 73 days or fewer over the five earlier years, test (b) would have held for 2028-29 and he would have had a third.

What Section 89A (now Section 158) actually does

Once you are ROR, India taxes residents on worldwide income, and the conservative reading is that dividends, interest and gains arising inside a 401(k) or IRA are your income as they accrue. The US taxes nothing until you withdraw. India's tax arrives first; the US tax arrives years later; and a foreign tax credit is given only in the year the income is offered to tax in India. The two never meet.

Section 89A fixes the timing, not the amount. Read with Rule 21AAA (Rule 74 from tax year 2026-27):

Condition or effectWhat the rule says
Who qualifiesA 'specified person': a resident of India who opened the account while non-resident in India and resident in the notified country
Which countriesNotified countries only. Notification 25/2022 (4 April 2022) names Canada, the UK and the USA
Which accountsAn account in that country taxed there on withdrawal or redemption, not on accrual
What movesIncome accrued in the account is taxed in India in the year the US taxes the withdrawal
What is excludedIncome already taxed in India, and income not taxable when it accrued because you were non-resident or RNOR or because of the treaty. Foreign tax on that excluded income is ignored for the credit
ScopeThe option covers all your specified accounts; you cannot pick one 401(k) and leave an IRA out
How and whenForm 10-EE (Form 40 from tax year 2026-27), filed electronically on or before the return due date for that year
Lock-inApplies to all later years and cannot be withdrawn
If you leave IndiaIf you become non-resident again, the option is deemed never exercised from that year, and income accrued since the election becomes taxable in the year before you became non-resident, with tax due by that later year's return due date

Roth accounts. A qualified Roth IRA withdrawal is not taxed by the US, so a Roth does not obviously meet the 'taxed on withdrawal' condition, and no CBDT clarification settles it. Treat a Roth as outside the election unless your CA has a reasoned basis.

The US side: penalty, withholding and the treaty pension article

10% additional tax. Under IRC Section 72(t), distributions before age 59 and a half generally attract a 10% additional tax on top of income tax. One exception matters to returnees: for a 401(k) (not an IRA), separating from that employer in or after the year you turn 55 removes it. Rolling a 401(k) into an IRA forfeits that exception.

Which kind of taxpayer you are. If you are a US citizen or still a green-card holder, the US taxes you on worldwide income regardless of where you live; the treaty's saving clause (Article 1(3)) preserves that, and the pension article does not override it. If you are an Indian citizen who has given up US residence, you are a nonresident alien and the treaty matters.

The treaty pension article. Article 20(1) of the India-US treaty says a private pension or annuity paid from the US to a resident of India may be taxed only in India. But Article 20(3) defines a pension as a periodic payment for past services. A lump-sum 401(k) or IRA cash-out is generally not periodic, and income not covered by another article that arises in the US may also be taxed in the US under Article 23(3).

Withholding. Publication 515 says a plan must withhold 30% on a US-source pension distribution to a foreign person unless a treaty exemption is documented; the payer may instead apply graduated rates to the part that arises from US services after 1986. The final US tax is settled on the nonresident return, and it is your US advisor's call.

Required minimum distributions. The US requires minimum annual withdrawals from a traditional IRA from the 'applicable age': 73 if you reach 72 after 2022 and 73 before 2033, and 75 if you reach 74 after 2032 (IRC 401(a)(9)(C)(v)), the first by 1 April of the following year. For anyone born in 1960 or later that is 75. Roth IRA owners have no lifetime RMDs.

A worked example: the same 401(k), two timings

Anand (born October 1971) holds a $400,000 401(k), all pre-tax, opened while he was a US resident and non-resident in India, so he is a specified person. He gave up his green card and left his US employer in May 2026, aged 54 but in the calendar year he turns 55. All dollar figures and growth rates are illustrative; the rules applied are real.

Timing A: withdraw $100,000 in December 2027, inside the RNOR window. India: the income accrued outside India and is paid into his US account while he is RNOR, so India taxes nothing. US: he is 56, but he separated from service in 2026, the year he turns 55, so the age-55 exception applies to a distribution from that employer's 401(k): 10% additional tax = $0. (Had he rolled the money into an IRA first, the exception would be lost and the additional tax would be 10% x $100,000 = $10,000.) US income tax on the distribution still applies. The plan withholds 30% = $30,000 by default unless documentation supports a lower amount, and the final figure is settled on his US return.

Timing B: keep the account until after 59 and a half, elect Section 158. He becomes ROR on 1 April 2028 with the account at $460,000. It grows by $20,000 a year and he withdraws everything, $520,000, in May 2031 (tax year 2031-32), after turning 59 and a half in April 2031, so no 10% additional tax.

Without the electionWith Form 40 filed
India taxes$20,000 accrual in each of 2028-29, 2029-30, 2030-31$60,000 in 2031-32, the withdrawal year ($520,000 minus $460,000)
Indian tax at a 30% marginal rateOn the conservative accrual reading, $6,000 a year, before any US tax exists$18,000, in 2031-32
US tax (assume 24% of the distribution)$124,800 in 2031$124,800 in 2031
US tax attributable to the India-taxed sliceArrives years after the Indian tax, so matching a credit is uncertain$124,800 x 60,000 / 520,000 = $14,400
Indian credit (lower of Indian tax and foreign tax on that income, Rule 76)Not established$14,400
Net Indian taxUp to $18,000$18,000 minus $14,400 = $3,600

The $20,000 of yearly growth after 1 April 2028 is accrued income India can tax; the election moves it to the withdrawal year, where the US tax on the same slice can be credited. Because the option is exercised, Rule 74(2)(b) keeps the accrual from his non-resident and RNOR years out of the computation (only the $60,000 is included), and the US tax on that excluded part is ignored for the credit. We do not compute the without-election column beyond the conservative accrual reading, because how India would treat the withdrawal year without the option is not settled. The 30% figure is India's top new-regime slab (income above Rs 24 lakh); surcharge and cess, which depend on total income, are left out to keep the arithmetic readable.

A dated decision timeline (Anand's dates; yours shift with your return date)

DateDecision pointRule
Before leaving the US (May 2026)Note your separation year: the age-55 exception applies to the 401(k) of an employer you leave in or after the calendar year you turn 55 (Anand turns 55 in October 2026, so it applies), and is lost if the money is rolled into an IRAIRC 72(t)
15 June 2026Arrival; 290 days in India in tax year 2026-27, so resident; RNOR under the 9-of-10 testSection 6
1 Apr 2026 to 31 Mar 2028RNOR window. Growth and any withdrawal first received outside India are outside Indian tax. A later transfer of money already received abroad is not new income; a withdrawal paid directly into an Indian account is received in India and is taxableSection 5(1) proviso; Rule 74(2)(b)
31 Jul 2027 and 31 Jul 2028Indian returns for the two RNOR years (due date for individuals without business income)Section 263(1)(c)
1 Apr 2028ROR begins; the account enters the Indian net and Schedule FA disclosureSection 6
On or before 31 Jul 2029Last date to file Form 40 for tax year 2028-29, the first ROR year, so that no year is taxed on accrual. Lock-in from then onRule 74(3) and (5)
April 2031Age 59 and a half; the 10% additional tax no longer appliesIRC 72(t)
May 2031Withdrawal; US tax withheld; India taxes the post-RNOR accrual in tax year 2031-32Rule 74(1)
By 31 Mar 2033Form 44 for the foreign tax credit, within twelve months of the end of tax year 2031-32, CA-verified because the foreign tax is above Rs 1 lakhRule 76(12), (16)
Age 75 (October 2046)Applicable age for someone reaching 74 after 2032; traditional IRA required minimum distributions begin, the first by 1 April 2047IRC 401(a)(9)(C)(v)

If you might leave India again, weigh Rule 74(4) before filing: becoming non-resident unwinds the election and pulls the deferred income into the preceding year.

Want a CA to handle this remotely?

How we help

  1. 1

    We fix your status for every year, in writing

    From your passport stamps and travel history we count days for each Indian tax year, test both RNOR conditions, and give you the exact dates your RNOR window opens and closes, the way Anand's table does above.

  2. 2

    We model the withdrawal years against your window

    We lay out the Indian tax for each timing you are weighing: inside the RNOR window, after it with the election, after it without. Your US advisor adds the US side; you see both in one place before anything is decided.

  3. 3

    We decide and file the Section 89A / Section 158 election

    We confirm you are a specified person, list every specified account (the option covers all of them), check the Rule 74(4) risk if you may leave India again, and file Form 10-EE or Form 40 before the return due date.

  4. 4

    We compute the Indian income on withdrawal

    We separate the accrual that India can tax from the non-resident and RNOR accrual it cannot, using your account statements and the balances on the date your status changed, so only the right slice enters your return.

  5. 5

    We claim the credit and keep Schedule FA right

    We file Form 44 with the US tax evidence within the twelve-month window, CA-verified where the foreign tax is Rs 1 lakh or more, and report the account in Schedule FA from your first ROR year.

Want us to say which papers matter on the call?

Documents you may need

Start with just your phone number. We'll explain which documents are needed on the call.

  • Date of return to India, passport stamps and travel history for the last ten years
  • 401(k) and IRA statements, including balances on 31 March of each Indian tax year and on your RNOR end date
  • Account opening dates and where you were resident then (for specified-person status)
  • Your US citizenship or green-card status and the date it ended, if it has
  • Form 1099-R or 1042-S and US tax returns for any withdrawal year
  • PAN and any Indian returns filed since you returned

Scope the India-side retirement-account review

We’ll identify the India-side work that needs reviewing from your residency position and retirement-account circumstances. US tax advice stays with your US adviser. Any filing is scoped and agreed separately after reviewing your circumstances. Compare countries.

Sources and references

  • Section 6(6), Income-tax Act 1961 (Section 6(13), Income-tax Act 2025): RNOR tests, 9 of 10 years non-resident or 729 days or less in 7 years
  • Section 5(1) proviso: an RNOR is not taxed on income accruing outside India unless received in India or from a business controlled or profession set up in India
  • Section 89A, 1961 Act (Section 158, Income-tax Act 2025); CBDT Notification 25/2022 dated 4 April 2022: Canada, the UK and the USA are notified countries
  • Rule 21AAA and Form 10-EE (Notification 24/2022); Rule 74 and Form 40, Income-tax Rules 2026: option by the return due date, all accounts, irrevocable, excludes non-resident and RNOR accruals
  • Rule 76 and Form 44 (formerly Rule 128 and Form 67): foreign tax credit, CA verification where foreign tax is Rs 1 lakh or more
  • India-US DTAA Article 20 (private pensions), Article 23 (other income), Article 1(3) saving clause, Article 25 (relief from double taxation)
  • IRC Section 72(t): 10% additional tax before age 59 1/2, separation-from-service at 55 exception for 401(k) plans only; RMDs from the applicable age of 73 or 75 under IRC 401(a)(9)(C)(v)

Common questions

Not during your RNOR years: income accruing outside India is outside the Indian net for an RNOR unless received in India. Once you are ROR, the conservative reading is that India can tax the growth as it accrues, which is exactly what the Section 89A (Section 158) election on Form 10-EE or Form 40 moves to the withdrawal year.

On or before the due date of your Indian return for the year you want the option to start, usually 31 July after the tax year ends for individuals without business income. Filing for your first ROR year means no year is taxed on accrual. Once filed it covers all your specified accounts, applies to every later year, and cannot be withdrawn.

Not under the election. Rule 74 (Rule 21AAA before 2026-27) excludes income that was not taxable in India when it accrued because you were non-resident or RNOR. In our example, the $460,000 balance on the day Anand became ROR stays out; only the later $60,000 of growth is taxed in India, in the withdrawal year.

Generally yes, if you withdraw before 59 and a half and the distribution is US-taxable, wherever you live. The main exception for returnees is the age-55 rule: if you left the employer sponsoring the 401(k) in or after the year you turned 55, that 401(k) is exempt. It does not apply to IRAs, so a rollover gives it up.

Partly, and only if you are not a US citizen or green-card holder. Article 20 gives India the sole right to tax a private pension paid to an Indian resident, but it defines a pension as a periodic payment. A lump-sum cash-out is generally outside it and may be taxed by the US under Article 23(3). US citizens remain fully taxable under the saving clause.

Under Rule 74(4), becoming non-resident unwinds the election from that year, and all income accrued since you elected becomes taxable in India in the year before you became non-resident, with the tax due by the return due date of the year you left. If a second move is likely, that belongs in the model before you file.

Where the general rule does not apply

Every rule below has a carve-out, a cut-off date or a condition that flips the answer. These are the ones that decide real cases.

Section 89A notified countries

Right now: USA, UK and Canada (Notification 25/2022). Australia appears in the department's Form 40 FAQ of March 2026 but no notification adding it has been traced.

Where it works differently

The account is in Australia
Treat it as not notified until the CBDT's current list confirms it. The Income-tax Department's Form 40 FAQ (March 2026) says the notified countries are the USA, the UK, Canada and Australia 'at present', but no gazette notification adding Australia has been found.
Only a notification under the section can add a country. A department FAQ is strong evidence but is not the instrument. Source of the FAQ: https://www.incometaxindia.gov.in/documents/d/guest/form-40-faqs
The account is in the UAE, Singapore or anywhere else not listed
Relief is unavailable. Accrual-basis taxation applies in India.
Only notified countries qualify. Most of this site's Gulf audience is excluded.
Claiming the relief for FY 2025-26 or earlier (1961 Act)
Form 10-EE must be filed on or before the return due date for the FIRST year of the claim. There is no condonation.
Rule 21AAA.
The relief is claimed for tax year 2026-27 or later
Cite s.158 of the Income-tax Act 2025 and Form 40 (formerly s.89A and Form 10-EE). FY 2025-26 and earlier years stay on s.89A, Rule 21AAA and Form 10-EE.
Year-split: the 1961 Act still governs income up to 31 March 2026. The Income-tax Department's 2025-Act navigator maps s.89A to s.158, and the Income-tax Rules 2026 replace Form 10-EE with Form 40.

Commonly got wrong

  • s.89A covers any foreign retirement account. Only USA, UK and Canada are notified.Section 89A relief covers retirement accounts in the United States, the United Kingdom and Canada. Australia appears in the department's Form 40 FAQ but has not been confirmed by notification; accounts in the UAE or Singapore do not qualify.

Income-tax return due dates

Right now: 31 July (no business or professional income, e.g. ITR-1 and ITR-2) / 31 August (business or profession, accounts not audited) / 31 October (audit cases and companies) / 30 November (transfer pricing, s.92E)

Where it works differently

AY 2026-27 audit case (Table sl. no. 2: companies and assessees whose accounts must be audited)
The 31 October 2026 date was extended to 21 November 2026, and the tax audit report from 30 September to 21 October 2026. Non-audit and transfer-pricing dates were not extended.
CBDT Circular 07/2026, 28 September 2026, F. No. 225/128/2026/ITA-II, https://www.incometax.gov.in/iec/foportal/sites/default/files/2026-09/Circular-7-2026.pdf
An NRI has business or professional income in India (for example a consultancy) but no audit
The due date is 31 August from AY 2026-27, not 31 July. An NRI with only rent, interest and capital gains stays on 31 July.
Finance Act 2026 Explanation 2 Table sl. no. 3 turns on business or profession income, not on the ITR form.
CBDT extends the date
Extensions are common and announced by press release. Never state a due date as immovable without checking the current year.
Administrative practice.
Carry-forward of losses is wanted
The ORIGINAL return must be within s.139(1). A belated return forfeits the carry-forward of business, speculation and capital losses (house-property loss and unabsorbed depreciation still carry forward).
s.80.

Commonly got wrong

  • The deadline is always 31 July. It is frequently extended, and is 31 October for audit cases.State the base date and note that extensions happen.
  • Every non-audit return is due on 31 July. From AY 2026-27 the Finance Act 2026 gave non-audit business and professional income a separate 31 August due date.For AY 2026-27 onwards the return is due on 31 July if you have no business income, and 31 August if you have business or professional income that is not audited.

Primary residence test: days in India

Right now: 182 days

Where it works differently

The person is an Indian citizen leaving India for employment abroad, or as a crew member of an Indian ship
Only the 182-day test applies. The 60-day secondary test is disabled.
Explanation 1(a) to s.6(1)
Counting days
The day of arrival AND the day of departure both count as days in India.
Settled administrative practice; partial days count as whole days.
The financial year straddles a move
Residence is decided for the WHOLE financial year, not from the date of the move. India has no split-year concept, unlike the UK.
s.6 is a full-year test.

Commonly got wrong

  • You become an NRI the day you leave India. True for FEMA, false for income tax. Under FEMA residence changes on departure with intent; under the Income-tax Act it is a full-year day count.Name which law you mean. Say 'non-resident under FEMA from the day you leave' or 'non-resident for income tax if you are in India under 182 days in that financial year'.
  • India has split-year treatment. It does not. Only the treaty tie-breaker resolves a dual-residence year.Point to Article 4 of the relevant DTAA.

RNOR qualification tests

Right now: Non-resident in 9 of the 10 preceding years, OR in India for 729 days or less in the 7 preceding years

Where it works differently

A long-term NRI returns to India permanently
Typically RNOR for two financial years, sometimes three depending on the return date and prior visits.
Both limbs are tested each year; the exact count depends on actual travel history.
The NRI visited India frequently while abroad
RNOR may last only one year, or not apply at all.
The 729-day limb is cumulative across seven years.

Commonly got wrong

  • RNOR always lasts three years. It depends on actual day counts. Two years is the common case; three is not automatic.Say 'usually two years, sometimes three, depending on your travel history', and compute it.
  • RNOR status exempts NRE interest. NRE exemption is tied to FEMA non-residence, which usually ends on permanent return, before RNOR does.Separate the two: RNOR covers foreign income; NRE exemption ends with FEMA residence.

Back in India with a 401(k) or IRA?

Send us your return date and account statements. A practising CA will map your RNOR window, model the Form 40 election and set your filing dates. Free call, no obligation.

A practising Chartered Accountant handles your Indian tax work.

We use your number to respond to your enquiry. Privacy policy.

Chat on WhatsApp

What to do next

Choose the next step that fits the question you are reading about.