Skip to content
Got a notice? Emergency response

Property, Sale

You claimed the exemption, then sold the new house too soon

You saved the capital-gains tax by buying a new house, and now you are selling that house within three years, and the old exemption is coming back to bite.

Some time ago you sold an Indian asset, saved the capital-gains tax by reinvesting in a new house under Section 54 or 54F, and moved on. Now, within three years, circumstances mean you are selling that new house too. What most people do not realise is that the earlier exemption came with a three-year lock-in, and selling the new house inside it does not just tax the new gain, it brings back the tax you saved the first time. Knowing how that recapture works before you sell avoids a nasty surprise.
Request a free CA call
Last reviewed: 26 July 20267 min readReviewed by Preetesh Maloo, CA

The short answer

The reinvestment exemption has a three-year lock-in on the new house. If you sell it within three years of buying or building it, the exemption is recaptured. Under Section 54, the new house's cost is reduced by the gain you had exempted, so you have a larger, and short-term, gain on this sale. Under Section 54F, the gain you had exempted is brought back and taxed directly as a long-term capital gain in the year you sell the new house, on top of any gain on the house itself. Either way, the tax you saved the first time comes back, so selling the new house inside three years undoes the benefit.

Is this your situation? Get a senior CA on it.

Free 15-minute call. We tell you what applies to you and what it costs, then you decide. You stay abroad.

Senior CA who specialises in NRI tax · we deal with the tax officer, you don't

Chat with a CA on WhatsApp

Related situations

The three-year lock-in

The reinvestment exemptions come with a condition that is easy to forget once the first sale is behind you: the new house has to be held for three years. If you transfer it within three years of buying or constructing it, the exemption you claimed is recaptured. Note that this lock-in is three years, not the twenty-four-month period that now decides long-term status generally; the reinvestment rules kept the three-year line.

So the question on selling a house you bought with exempt money is simply how long ago you bought or built it. Inside three years, the recapture rules below apply. Past three years, the exemption is safe and the new sale is taxed on its own footing. Getting the date right is the whole of it.

How Section 54 recaptures the exemption

Where you had claimed Section 54, the recapture works through the cost of the new house (Section 54). For computing the gain on this sale, the cost of the new house is reduced by the amount of the capital gain you exempted earlier. So your cost is artificially lowered, which produces a larger gain on the sale of the new house, and because you held it less than three years, that gain is short-term, taxed at your slab rate rather than the concessional long-term rate.

The effect is that the tax you saved the first time is effectively recovered through a bigger, higher-rate gain on the second sale. A practising CA computes this correctly, applying the reduced cost, so the return reflects the recapture rather than understating the gain and inviting a notice.

How Section 54F recaptures, and the TDS

Where you had claimed Section 54F, the mechanism is different and more direct (Section 54F). The gain you had exempted is deemed to be long-term capital gain of the year in which you sell the new house, and taxed as such, separately from and in addition to any gain on the new house itself. So you are taxed both on the recaptured old gain and on whatever the new house made.

Either way, as an NRI selling the new house, the buyer deducts TDS under Section 195, and a Form 13 certificate can set that to your real position. Because the recapture makes the true taxable amount larger than a simple gain on the new house, getting the computation and the certificate right matters, so the withholding and the return line up and the recaptured tax is paid correctly rather than surfacing as a demand later.

What's involved

What the CA actually does

  1. 1

    We check the three-year date

    We establish exactly when you bought or built the new house, because selling inside three years triggers the recapture and past it does not.

  2. 2

    We compute the recapture correctly

    We apply the right mechanism, the reduced cost under Section 54 or the direct add-back under Section 54F, so the taxable gain is computed properly.

  3. 3

    We handle the TDS

    We file a Form 13 reflecting the real taxable amount, including the recapture, so the buyer's Section 195 deduction is right.

  4. 4

    We file it cleanly

    We carry the recaptured gain and the new sale into your return so the position is settled rather than left to a later notice.

What to have ready

Documents you'll typically need

  • The purchase or construction records of the new house, with dates
  • The earlier sale and the exemption you had claimed
  • The current sale documents for the new house
  • Your prior returns showing the Section 54 or 54F claim

Your destination country can change the details

Requirements differ from one consulate, university and visa route to the next, how recent the figures must be, how long funds must have been held, and which certificates are mandatory. We assemble the documents around the exact checklist you're applying under. To see how India's tax treaty with your country of residence affects related filings, set your country below or compare all 46 countries.

References on this page

  • The reinvestment exemption carries a 3-year lock-in on the new house (not 24 months)
  • Section 54: the new house's cost is reduced by the exempted gain, producing a larger short-term gain
  • Section 54F(3): the exempted gain is taxed directly as long-term capital gain in the year the new house is sold
  • Section 195 TDS applies to the NRI's sale of the new house

Frequently asked questions

Common questions

Yes. The reinvestment exemption has a three-year lock-in, and selling the new house inside it recaptures the exemption. The tax you saved the first time is brought back, in addition to any gain on the new house.

The cost of the new house is reduced by the gain you had exempted, which produces a larger gain on this sale. Because you held the house under three years, that gain is short-term, taxed at your slab rate.

The gain you had exempted is taxed directly as a long-term capital gain in the year you sell the new house, separate from and in addition to any gain on the house itself. It is a different mechanism from Section 54's cost reduction.

Yes. The lock-in is three years from the purchase or construction of the new house. Sell after that and the earlier exemption is safe; only the gain on the new house itself is taxed, on its own footing.

The exceptions that change the answer

Where the general rule stops applying to you

Every rule below has a carve-out, a cut-off date or a condition that flips the answer. These are the ones that decide real cases.

LTCG rate: assets other than STT-paid listed equity (includes property)

Right now: 12.5% without indexation

Where it works differently

A RESIDENT individual or HUF sells land or a building acquired before 23 July 2024
May elect the lower of 12.5% without indexation or 20% with indexation.
Grandfathering proviso inserted by Finance (No. 2) Act 2024.
A NON-RESIDENT sells the same property
12.5% without indexation only. The election is NOT available.
The grandfathering proviso is expressly limited to resident individuals and HUFs. This is the highest-value NRI distinction on the site.
Shares or debentures of an Indian company were bought in convertible foreign exchange by a non-resident
The first proviso to s.48 computes the gain in that foreign currency, neutralising rupee depreciation. This is separate from, and not lost with, indexation.
First proviso to s.48 survives the 2024 changes.
Adding surcharge and cess
Surcharge on capital gains under s.111A/112/112A is capped at 15%, plus 4% health and education cess.
The cap applies to gains under s.111A, s.112 and s.112A.

Commonly got wrong

  • NRIs can choose 20% with indexation on property bought before July 2024. The election is resident-only. Stating otherwise understates an NRI's tax, which is the worst direction to be wrong in.Residents may elect 20% with indexation for pre-23-July-2024 land and buildings. Non-residents get 12.5% without indexation, full stop.
  • LTCG on property is 20%. Stale since 23 July 2024 unless the transfer predates it.12.5% for transfers on or after 23 July 2024.

Cap on s.54 and s.54F exemption

Right now: Rs 10 crore

Where it works differently

The replacement house is outside India
No exemption. The house must be in India.
'in India' was inserted by Finance Act 2014, from AY 2015-16. This is the single most important s.54 point for NRIs.
Claiming s.54F
The ENTIRE net consideration must be reinvested, not just the gain, and the taxpayer must not own more than one other residential house. A house owned ABROAD counts.
Proviso to s.54F(1).

Commonly got wrong

  • An NRI can claim s.54 by buying a house abroad. The replacement property must be in India since AY 2015-16.The new house must be in India.
  • s.54 and s.54F both need only the gain reinvested. s.54 needs the gain; s.54F needs the whole net consideration.Section 54 requires only the capital GAIN to be reinvested. Section 54F requires the entire NET CONSIDERATION. Both cap the exemption at Rs 10 crore, and both need the new house to be in India.

Section 54 reinvestment time windows

Right now: Purchase within 1 year before or 2 years after the transfer; construction within 3 years

Where it works differently

The return due date arrives before the purchase
The unutilised gain must be deposited in a Capital Gains Account Scheme account BEFORE the due date, or the exemption is lost.
s.54(2). The single commonest way NRIs lose this exemption.
The gain came from an under-construction flat
The holding period runs from the allotment date in most rulings, not from possession.
Settled by several ITAT and High Court decisions.
The new house is sold within three years
The exemption is withdrawn and taxed in the year of that sale.
s.54(1) proviso.

Commonly got wrong

  • You have two years to reinvest, so no action is needed before filing. If the due date falls first, the money must sit in a CGAS account by then.You have two years to buy, but if your filing due date comes first, park the unutilised gain in a Capital Gains Account Scheme account before that date or the exemption goes.

Related

If this matched your situation, these go further

Saving capital-gains tax by reinvesting in another house (Section 54)Saving tax on a plot or commercial sale: how Section 54F worksYou have not reinvested yet, and the return is due: the CGAS lifelineForm 13 lower-TDS certificate (property sale)NRI ITR filing (we file for you)DTAA TDS recoveryCapital gains calculatorProperty sale TDS calculator

Selling a house you bought with exempt money?

Tell us when you bought it and what you had claimed. A practising CA will compute the recapture on a free call, no obligation.

Request a free CA call

No card, no obligation. All certification and filing work is handled by ICAI-registered practising Chartered Accountants.