The short answer is above. The first sections below cover what most readers need; tap any later heading to open the detail.
Why every Indian fund is a PFIC, and why each one needs its own Form 8621
Under IRC Section 1297 a foreign corporation is a PFIC if 75% or more of its gross income is passive, or if on average at least 50% of its assets produce passive income. An Indian mutual fund holds shares, bonds and cash, so it meets both tests. Equity funds, ELSS, debt funds, index funds, ETFs and fund-of-funds are all caught. Each scheme is normally tested as its own PFIC, fund by fund.
The IRS instructions are explicit: a separate Form 8621 must be filed for each PFIC, attached to your return by its due date including extensions. Five funds means five forms, every year, even in a year you did nothing, unless the small-holding exception below or another exception in Treas. Reg. 1.1298-1(c) applies.
The small-holding exception is narrower than people think. Under Treas. Reg. 1.1298-1(c)(2) you can skip Form 8621 for a fund for a year only if all of these hold: the total value of all your PFIC holdings on the last day of the year is $25,000 or less ($50,000 if married filing jointly); you had no excess distribution from that fund and no gain on redeeming it that year; and you have not made a QEF election for it. A fund under a mark-to-market election still needs its form. The moment you redeem anything, the exception is gone for that fund.
Missing forms keep the whole year open. Under IRC Section 6501(c)(8), when a required Form 8621 is not filed, the IRS's time to assess tax for that year does not run out until three years after the information is finally provided. If the failure was due to reasonable cause and not wilful neglect, Section 6501(c)(8)(B) limits that extended period to the items related to the failure. That is why old, unreported folios are worth dealing with deliberately.
The three US tax methods, side by side
| Default (Section 1291) | QEF (Section 1295) | Mark-to-market (Section 1296) | |
|---|---|---|---|
| When you are taxed | On redemption, or on an 'excess distribution' | Every year on your share of the fund's earnings | Every year on the rise in December 31 value |
| Character | Past-year slices at the top rate for that year; current-year slice as ordinary income | Ordinary earnings and net capital gain keep their character | Ordinary income; losses only up to prior inclusions |
| Interest charge | Yes, Section 6621 underpayment rate, compounded daily | No | No |
| What it needs | Full purchase and redemption history | A PFIC Annual Information Statement from the fund | A year-end value for every fund, every year |
| Practical for Indian funds? | Applies automatically if you elect nothing | Generally no: Indian fund houses generally do not issue the statement; check each fund | Usually the workable election, if each fund qualifies |
Excess distribution. A distribution is 'excess' to the extent it is more than 125% of the average distributions from that fund over the previous three years. Under the Form 8621 instructions the entire gain on a redemption of a Section 1291 fund is treated as an excess distribution. It is divided by the number of days you held the units and allocated day by day to each year. The slice for the current year is ordinary income. Each earlier year's slice is taxed at the highest individual rate in force for that year (37% for 2018 to 2025), and interest runs on that tax from the original due date of that year's return to the due date of the current year's return.
Mark-to-market. It is available only for 'marketable stock'. Treas. Reg. 1.1296-2(d) extends that to a foreign fund that issues shares redeemable at net asset value if, throughout the year, it meets eight conditions, including more than 100 holders, a minimum investment no higher than $10,000, prices published at least weekly, independently audited public accounts, and regulation as an investment company by a foreign government. Indian schemes are SEBI-regulated, publish NAVs daily through AMFI and have small minimums, which is why mark-to-market is the method US preparers usually reach for. Your CPA confirms each fund against the eight conditions.
QEF. It would give the gentlest result, but the fund must give you a PFIC Annual Information Statement showing your share of its ordinary earnings and net capital gain. Indian AMCs generally do not produce one (confirm with each fund house), so for Indian funds QEF is usually not available in practice.
A worked example: one fund, $10,000 of gain, three outcomes
Divya lives in Seattle and files as a US tax resident. On 1 January 2021 she invested Rs 7,30,000 in an Indian equity fund, $10,000 at an assumed Rs 73 to the dollar. She redeemed the whole holding on 31 December 2025 for Rs 17,00,000, $20,000 at an assumed Rs 85. Her US gain is $20,000 minus $10,000 = $10,000. She made no election, so the default applies. Her ordinary bracket is 24%. (Exchange rates and fund values are illustrative; the tax rules and IRS interest rates are real.)
Step 1: spread the gain by day. Counting from the day after purchase, she held the units for 1,825 days. Gain per day = $10,000 / 1,825 = $5.4795.
| Year | Days | Gain allocated | Tax | Interest to 15 Apr 2026 |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| 2021 | 364 | $1,994.52 | 37% = $737.97 | $236.40 |
| 2022 | 365 | $2,000.00 | 37% = $740.00 | $183.52 |
| 2023 | 365 | $2,000.00 | 37% = $740.00 | $116.84 |
| 2024 | 366 | $2,005.48 | 37% = $742.03 | $53.49 |
| 2025 (current) | 365 | $2,000.00 | 24% = $480.00 | none |
Step 2: add it up. Deferred tax on the four past years = $2,960.00. Interest = $590.25, computed at the IRS underpayment rates for each quarter (from 4% in mid-2022 up to 8% through 2024, 7% in 2025, 6% from April 2026), compounded daily from each year's original return due date (18 April 2022 for 2021, 18 April 2023 for 2022, 15 April 2024 for 2023, 15 April 2025 for 2024) to 15 April 2026, the due date of the 2025 return. Current-year tax = $480.00. Total US cost: $2,960.00 + $590.25 + $480.00 = $4,030.25, or about 40% of the gain.
Step 3: compare. Had Divya made a mark-to-market election in 2021, the same $10,000 would have been taxed year by year as ordinary income: 24% x $10,000 = $2,400, with no interest charge. For contrast, a US-domiciled fund held more than a year would usually see long-term capital-gain rates of 0%, 15% or 20%: at 15%, $1,500.
Step 4: the Indian tax. India taxes the same redemption. Her rupee gain is Rs 17,00,000 minus Rs 7,30,000 = Rs 9,70,000. Equity-fund long-term gains above Rs 1,25,000 are taxed at 12.5%: (Rs 9,70,000 minus Rs 1,25,000) x 12.5% = Rs 1,05,625, about $1,243, before surcharge and cess. Do not assume this Indian tax reduces the $4,030.25. On a disposition, the Form 8621 rules that let foreign tax offset each year's PFIC tax apply only to the part of the gain that would be a section 1248 dividend, and that is not established for Divya's fund, so the example applies no credit. Whether any credit is available under the general foreign-tax-credit rules is your CPA's computation; the India-side job is to prove the Indian figure with the computation and the TDS certificate.
What the India side actually produces
Indian records are built for Indian tax: financial years from April to March, rupee figures, capital-gains statements that group SIP instalments. Form 8621 needs calendar years, dollars and lot-level detail. Converting one into the other is a data and reconciliation job, and it is ours.
| Item in the pack | Indian source | Why the CPA needs it |
|---|---|---|
| Fund inventory: every folio, scheme, ISIN and plan | Consolidated Account Statement (CAS) and registrar records from CAMS and KFintech | One Form 8621 per fund, none missed |
| Purchase lots: date, rupees, units, NAV, each SIP instalment separately | Registrar transaction statements since inception | Holding-period days for Section 1291; cost basis for mark-to-market |
| Redemptions and switches, with units and proceeds | Registrar transaction statements | Each is a disposal; a switch between schemes is a sale and a purchase |
| IDCW (dividend) payouts by date | Registrar statements, bank credits | The 125% excess-distribution test needs three years of distribution history |
| December 31 NAV for every year held | AMFI NAV history | Mark-to-market inclusions and year-end values |
| Indian tax withheld and Indian capital-gains computation | TDS certificates and our Indian computation | Foreign tax allocated on Form 8621 |
| Peak and year-end value per folio | Statements and AMFI NAVs | FBAR and Form 8938 figures |
Every figure is shown in rupees and dollars, with the exchange-rate basis stated so your CPA can apply the convention they use. The pack reconciles units end to end, so the year-end balance in our schedule equals the balance on your CAS. We do not prepare Form 8621 or your US return; we hand your CPA the inputs.
FBAR and Form 8938: the same funds, two more reports
FBAR (FinCEN Form 114). A US person files an FBAR if the combined value of their foreign financial accounts was more than $10,000 at any time in the calendar year. The definition in 31 CFR 1010.350 expressly includes an account with a mutual fund or similar pooled fund that sells shares to the public with regular NAV pricing and redemptions, so an Indian mutual-fund folio is reported alongside your NRE and NRO accounts. It is filed electronically with FinCEN, not with your tax return; it is due April 15, with an automatic extension to October 15.
Form 8938. It applies above higher thresholds: for a US resident, more than $50,000 at year-end or $75,000 at any time if single, $100,000 or $150,000 if married filing jointly (higher thresholds apply to those living abroad). Under the duplicative-reporting rule, a fund reported on Form 8621 does not have to be listed again on Form 8938; instead you identify the Form 8621 filings in Part IV. The FBAR has no such exception, so the same folio usually appears on both the FBAR and Form 8621.
Legacy folios: the options and what each one triggers
Many readers have folios opened years ago that were never reported. These are the paths and their US consequences. Which one fits is a decision for you and your CPA; our part is the numbers for each.
| Path | What it triggers |
|---|---|
| Keep the folio and stay on the default method | Form 8621 each year (unless the $25,000 / $50,000 exception applies); any later redemption is taxed as an excess distribution with interest back to your first year |
| Keep it and elect mark-to-market from now | In the first election year, the gain built up to that December 31 is taxed under Section 1291 (top rates plus interest) as if the fund were sold; after that, year-by-year ordinary income |
| Elect QEF with a deemed-sale election | Needs the fund's PFIC Annual Information Statement, which Indian funds generally do not issue, so usually unavailable |
| Redeem | The whole gain is an excess distribution in the year of redemption, plus Indian tax on the same gain; the folio leaves the FBAR from the following year |
If past years were never reported. The IRS Streamlined Filing Compliance Procedures are open to taxpayers who certify that the failure was non-willful and who are not already under examination. The domestic version (for US residents) also requires that you previously filed a US return, if required, for each of the last three years. It requires amended returns for those three years, including every missing Form 8621 and Form 8938, and FBARs for the last six years, with a 5% penalty on the highest year-end aggregate value of the covered assets. That base includes assets that should have been on an FBAR or Form 8938, and also reported assets whose income was left off the return. Your US advisor decides whether this route fits.
On the India side, legacy folios often have stale details: resident status never changed to NRI, an old resident savings account as the bank mandate, or KYC that needs updating before any redemption can be paid out. We sort those out with the registrar first, so the history we rebuild is complete and the folio is usable whatever you and your CPA decide.