Question 1

I'm an Indian living in France. Why is India taking so much tax from my investments?

Accepted Answer

Short version: India treats you as an NRI and deducts 30% TDS on your FD interest by default. That's the rate for “foreigner, no treaty claimed.” But India and France have a tax treaty (called DTAA) that caps this at 10%. The difference — 20%, is money you're entitled to but aren't getting back. Most Indians in Paris don't know this exists.

Question 2

What exactly is a DTAA? Why should I care?

Accepted Answer

DTAA stands for Double Taxation Avoidance Agreement. It's a deal between two countries that says “hey, let's not tax the same person twice on the same income.” India has signed these with 90+ countries, including France. For you, it means lower tax rates on your Indian income, if you claim it. The catch? Nobody tells you about it. Not your bank, not most CAs.

Question 3

How much money are we actually talking about?

Accepted Answer

Depends on your investments. Quick math: ₹15 lakh FD at 7% earns ~₹1.05 lakh interest. Without DTAA, your bank deducts ₹31,500 (30%). With DTAA, it should be ₹10,500 (10%). That's ₹21,000 saved every year, just on one FD. Add mutual funds, dividends, NRO interest, and it stacks up.

Question 4

I already pay tax in France. Am I being taxed twice?

Accepted Answer

Possibly, yes. France taxes worldwide income. your Indian-source income is taxed at source. Without DTAA, you're paying full tax in both places. The treaty fixes this: TDS is deducted at the lower rate, you claim a Foreign Tax Credit in France for TDS already paid. Without DTAA, you overpay on TDS AND can't fully offset it.

Question 5

Is this legal? Will I get into trouble?

Accepted Answer

Claiming DTAA is your legal right under an international treaty India signed and ratified. It's not a loophole, not aggressive planning, not avoidance. You're asking India to follow its own treaty obligations. Thousands of Indians in Paris do this every year. The Income Tax Department has a standard process for it.

Question 6

How does India decide my tax rate as a French NRI?

Accepted Answer

India's residency test is in Section 6 of the Income-tax Act. You're an NRI for an FY (April–March) if you fail BOTH limbs: under 182 days in India in that FY, AND not 60+ days in the FY plus 365+ days across the 4 preceding FYs (the 60-day limb stretches to 182 if you left India for employment). On top of that, since FY 2020-21, an Indian citizen OR person of Indian origin (PIO) with Indian-source income above ₹15 lakh becomes RNOR at 120 days (Section 6(1) Explanation 1(b) proviso, read with Section 6(6)(c)) — distinct from the Section 6(1A) "deemed-resident" rule, which applies only to Indian citizens (NOT PIOs) who are not tax-resident anywhere. As an NRI, only your Indian-source income is taxable in India, but at steeper default rates. FD interest at 30%, dividends at 20%. DTAA brings these down.

Question 7

What's the difference between TDS and my actual tax liability?

Accepted Answer

TDS is the tax your bank or AMC pulls at source before paying you, an advance payment to the government, not your final bill. Your actual tax liability is usually lower once DTAA treaty rates apply. If TDS deducted exceeds actual tax owed, the gap refunds when you file your ITR. That's exactly what DTAA recovery is about.

Question 8

Do I need to file tax returns in both France and India?

Accepted Answer

Yes, most likely. You file in France because they tax worldwide income. You file in India to claim DTAA rates and get refunds on excess TDS. The ITR in India is where you attach your TRC and Form 10F to prove you're eligible for treaty rates. Skip it, and the excess TDS stays with the government.

Question 9

What's this 4% cess everyone talks about?

Accepted Answer

India adds a 4% Health & Education Cess on top of your income tax. So when people say “30% TDS,” the actual deduction is 31.2% (30% + 4% cess on that). The DTAA rate doesn't have cess on top, so when we say 10%, that's the final number. Another small saving most people miss.

Question 10

What happens if I become a resident of India again?

Accepted Answer

Two ways to flip resident under Section 6(1): 182+ days in a financial year, OR 60+ days in the FY combined with 365+ days across the prior 4 FYs. Indian citizens visiting from abroad get a relaxed 182-day single-test (subject to the 120-day rule below). Once resident, DTAA rates stop applying for new income. But any claims you filed for your NRI years are still valid, those refunds will still come through. Plan your return date with the day-count in mind.

Question 11

I'm moving back to India. What's RNOR and why should I care?

Accepted Answer

RNOR means Resident but Not Ordinarily Resident. It's a special status available for 1-3 years after you return to India. During RNOR, your foreign income (salary from France, overseas investments) is NOT taxable in India. Only Indian-source income is taxed. Banks won't tell you about this. Most CAs won't bring it up. But it can save Indians in Paris lakhs in the transition period. File as RNOR on your ITR, don't let anyone file you as a regular resident in your first year back.

Question 12

What's the 120-day deemed resident trap?

Accepted Answer

Budget 2020 added a proviso to Section 6(1) Explanation 1(b) (NOT Section 6(1A) — those are two different rules). If you're an Indian citizen OR person of Indian origin (PIO) with Indian-source income above ₹15 lakh and you spend 120-181 days in India, the 182-day relaxation is withdrawn — you become resident under the 60-day test. By default you fall into RNOR under Section 6(6)(c), so foreign income stays exempt, but Indian-source income gets taxed at resident slab rates. This catches Indians in Paris who visit India frequently, say 4 months for family reasons. Count your days carefully. 119 days = NRI. 120 days with ₹15L+ Indian income = RNOR. One day makes the difference. Separately, Section 6(1A) “deemed resident” applies only to stateless Indian citizens not tax-resident anywhere — a narrower rule that's often confused with this one.

Question 13

Which of my Indian investments are affected by DTAA?

Accepted Answer

Pretty much everything that earns income in India: Fixed Deposits (FD interest), NRO savings account interest, mutual fund gains (both equity and debt), dividends from Indian shares, bonds and NCDs. The one exception: rental income and property sale gains, these are usually taxed the same with or without DTAA.

Question 14

Do mutual fund gains benefit from DTAA for French NRIs?

Accepted Answer

For equity mutual funds, the India-France treaty doesn't reduce the rate below what India charges (12.5%). So there's no direct DTAA saving on equity MF gains for Indians in Paris. Where DTAA really helps you is on FD interest (30% → 10%) and dividends (20% → 10%). Focus your recovery efforts there.

Question 15

What about dividends from Reliance, TCS, Infosys?

Accepted Answer

Default TDS on dividends for NRIs is 20%. Under the France DTAA, it drops to 10%. So every dividend payout from any Indian company. Reliance, HDFC, Infosys, wherever you hold shares, is being overtaxed by 10%. If you're holding a dividend-heavy portfolio, this adds up fast.

Question 16

Should I move my FDs from NRO to NRE account?

Accepted Answer

NRE FDs are tax-free in India, no TDS at all. NRO FDs face 30% TDS (or 10% with DTAA). So yes, for fresh deposits, NRE is better tax-wise. But NRO accounts hold your Indian-earned income (rent, dividends, interest), and you can't just move that to NRE. For the money stuck in NRO, DTAA is your best friend.

Question 17

I invest through apps like Groww, Zerodha, Kuvera. Does DTAA apply?

Accepted Answer

Absolutely. DTAA applies regardless of which platform you use. Groww, Zerodha, Kuvera, Coin, MFUtility, they all route through AMCs that deduct TDS. The TDS shows up in your 26AS the same way. The platform doesn't matter. What matters is whether you've claimed the treaty rate.

Question 18

What's the difference between NRO and NRE accounts?

Accepted Answer

NRE (Non-Resident External): for money you earn abroad and send to India. Interest is completely tax-free in India. You can repatriate freely. NRO (Non-Resident Ordinary): for money you earn in India (rent, dividends, sale proceeds). Interest is taxable at 30% TDS. Repatriation has limits. DTAA helps you reduce the NRO TDS from 30% to 10%.

Question 19

My bank doesn't know about DTAA. What do I do?

Accepted Answer

Happens all the time. Branch-level staff often have no idea what DTAA is. You need to submit your TRC and Form 10F to the bank's NRI cell or compliance department, not the branch. Some banks (SBI, HDFC, ICICI) have dedicated NRI desks. If they refuse, escalate to the banking ombudsman. Or skip the bank entirely, file your ITR with DTAA rates and get the excess back as a refund.

Question 20

Can my NRO account be converted to a regular account if I return?

Accepted Answer

Yes. When you become a resident again, your NRO becomes a regular savings account and NRE becomes a regular resident account (or RFC. Resident Foreign Currency). Any DTAA claims from your NRI years are still valid. Process the conversion through your bank within a reasonable time after returning.

Question 21

I have FDs in multiple banks. Do I need separate TRCs for each?

Accepted Answer

No. One TRC covers all your Indian financial relationships. You get one TRC from DGFiP (Direction Générale des Finances Publiques), local SIE/SIP and submit copies to each bank/AMC. Same with Form 10F, one filing on the income tax portal covers everything. Just make sure you submit before the TDS deduction date, not after.

Question 22

I'm selling a flat in India. How does TDS work?

Accepted Answer

When an NRI sells property, the BUYER must deduct TDS, not the bank, not you. For long-term gains (held 24+ months): 12.5% Section 195 TDS on the FULL sale value (effective 13–14.95% with surcharge + cess), not just the gain. For short-term holdings: 30% + surcharge + 4% cess on full sale value. The buyer deposits via Form 27Q (NOT Form 26QB — that's for resident-to-resident sales at 1% under Section 194-IA). Most treaties don't reduce property TDS because real estate is taxed where it sits — the lever is Form 13 under Section 197.

Question 23

Does DTAA help with property sale tax?

Accepted Answer

Usually not. Most DTAAs, including India-France, say immovable property gains are taxable in the country where the property is located. So India's rate applies. However, you CAN apply for a lower TDS certificate (Form 13) if your actual capital gain is less than the sale price. This prevents excessive TDS upfront.

Question 24

What about rental income from my Indian property?

Accepted Answer

Your tenant (or property manager) must deduct TDS at 31.2% on the gross rent. DTAA typically doesn't reduce this, rental income from Indian property is taxable in India under most treaties. But you CAN claim deductions (municipal taxes, 30% standard deduction) in your ITR to reduce the effective tax. Make sure your tenant is actually depositing the TDS, check your 26AS.

Question 25

I inherited property in India. Any tax implications?

Accepted Answer

Inheritance itself isn't taxed in India, there's no inheritance tax. But the moment you earn income from it (rent) or sell it (capital gains), you're taxed as an NRI. Your cost basis for capital gains is the price the original owner paid, not the market value when you inherited. This can mean bigger gains and bigger TDS.

Question 26

The buyer deducted TDS on the full sale price, not just my profit. Why?

Accepted Answer

This is the #1 complaint from Indians in Paris selling property. The buyer deducts TDS at 12.5% on the ENTIRE sale price, not your capital gain. So if you bought for ₹50 lakh and sold for ₹2 crore, your actual gain is ₹1.5 crore. Tax at 12.5% should be ₹18.75 lakh. But the buyer deducts 12.5% of ₹2 crore = ₹25 lakh. That's ₹6.25 lakh over-deducted, stuck with the government until your ITR refund comes through (3-6 months). The fix: apply for a Form 13 (lower TDS certificate) BEFORE the sale.

Question 27

Indexation benefit was removed in 2024. How bad is it?

Accepted Answer

Bad for long-held properties. Before Budget 2024, you paid 20% LTCG but could adjust the purchase price for inflation using the Cost Inflation Index. A flat bought for ₹10 lakh in 2005 would have an indexed cost of ~₹35 lakh, massively reducing your taxable gain. Now it's a flat 12.5% without any inflation adjustment. For properties held 15-20+ years, the new rule can actually mean MORE tax despite the lower rate. Run the numbers before selling.

Question 28

I gave someone a GPA to manage my property. Can they sell it?

Accepted Answer

This is a real danger zone. The Supreme Court (Suraj Lamp case, 2012) ruled that property sales through General Power of Attorney are NOT valid title transfers. Yet it still happens. French NRIs have lost properties to GPA holders who sold without consent, mortgaged for personal loans, or transferred to their own name. Always use a Special Power of Attorney (SPA) with specific, limited authority. Get it attested at the Indian Embassy/Consulate or apostilled, then stamped and registered in India within 90 days. Never give open-ended GPA for property.

Question 29

What's a TRC and how do I get one from France?

Accepted Answer

TRC is your Tax Residency Certificate, proof that you live in France and are registered as a tax resident there. You get it from DGFiP (Direction Générale des Finances Publiques), local SIE/SIP. Apply for the Attestation de résidence fiscale at your local SIE (Service des Impôts des Entreprises) or, for individuals, the SIP (Service des Impôts des Particuliers). The standard form is bilingual French/English (modèle 730-SD style) and meets OECD format. Most SIE offices issue it in 1-2 weeks. Paris and Lyon turnaround is faster than provincial offices. Costs Free (DGFiP/SIE issues Attestation de résidence fiscale at no charge). Lasts Per tax year. Without it, India won't give you treaty rates. It's the single most important document.

Question 30

What is Form 10F? How do I fill it?

Accepted Answer

Form 10F is a self-declaration you file on India's income tax portal (incometax.gov.in). It asks basic stuff: your name, country, tax ID in France, which DTAA article you're claiming. Takes 5 minutes. You need a PAN and login to file it. Without Form 10F, even a valid TRC won't work.

Question 31

What is Form 26AS and why is it important?

Accepted Answer

Think of 26AS as your TDS receipt book. It's a statement that shows every rupee of tax deducted from your income, who deducted it, when, how much, which section. This is the document that proves how much you've been overpaying. Upload it on TrustNRI and we'll show you the gap in 2 minutes.

Question 32

What are Forms 15CA and 15CB? When do I need them?

Accepted Answer

These come up when you're sending money OUT of India (repatriation). 15CA is an online form you fill declaring the payment. 15CB is a certificate from a CA confirming the tax treatment. You need these for NRO repatriation above a certain limit. Not directly related to DTAA claims, but important for Indians in Paris moving money between countries.

Question 33

Can I get back TDS that was already deducted at 30%?

Accepted Answer

Yes. File your ITR claiming the treaty rate. Attach your TRC and Form 10F. The difference between what was deducted (30%) and what should have been (10%) comes back as a refund. Processing time: typically 3-6 months after filing.

Question 34

What about past years? I've been overpaying for years.

Accepted Answer

Under Section 119(2)(b), you can file for condonation of delay and claim refunds for up to 5 past Assessment Years (CBDT Circular 11/2024). If you've been losing €1,320/year for 5 years, that's €6,600 with the government. Plus 6% annual interest under Section 244A. Many Indians in Paris recover a serious chunk through this.

Question 35

How long does recovery take end to end?

Accepted Answer

Current year: 3-6 months after ITR filing. Past years (condonation): 6-12 months. The bottleneck is usually the TRC from DGFiP (Direction Générale des Finances Publiques), local SIE/SIP. Once docs are ready, we file everything together. You don't need to visit India. Refund goes directly to your bank account linked to PAN.

Question 36

What if my ITR was already filed without claiming DTAA?

Accepted Answer

You can file a revised return (if within the deadline) or apply for rectification under Section 154. For past years where the deadline has passed, that's where condonation under Section 119(2)(b) comes in. Bottom line: it's almost never too late. There's always a route.

Question 37

Is there a risk of triggering a tax audit?

Accepted Answer

Claiming DTAA doesn't increase audit risk. You're using a standard treaty provision. The Income Tax Department sees thousands of these claims. As long as your TRC is valid and your numbers match 26AS, there's nothing unusual about the filing.

Question 38

What's my residential status and why does it matter?

Accepted Answer

India decides your tax rate based on Section 6 of the Income-tax Act. Under 182 days in a financial year AND under 60 days (or under 365 days across the prior 4 FYs) = NRI. Indian citizens/PIOs at 120-181 days with Indian-source income above ₹15 lakh become RNOR under the 2020 rule (Section 6(1) Explanation 1(b) plus Section 6(6)(c)). Over 182 days = resident. Getting this wrong means wrong TDS rates, wrong ITR form, and potentially wrong DTAA claims. Count your days carefully.

Question 39

Do I need to report my Indian income in France?

Accepted Answer

Yes. France taxes worldwide income, so your Indian FD interest, dividends, and capital gains need to be reported on your France tax return too. The good news: you claim a Foreign Tax Credit for whatever India deducted. DTAA ensures you're not double-taxed, but only if you claim it in both countries.

Question 40

My TRC is from last year. Can I still use it?

Accepted Answer

TRCs are valid for Per tax year. If yours has expired, you need a fresh one for the current period. You can't use last year's TRC for this year's claim. Set a reminder — DGFiP (Direction Générale des Finances Publiques), local SIE/SIP processes applications faster if you apply early.

Question 41

I forgot to submit TRC to my bank. Now what?

Accepted Answer

If TDS was already deducted at 30%, the ship hasn't sailed. Submit TRC now for future deductions. For the excess already deducted, file your ITR claiming DTAA rates and get it back as a refund. Prevention from next quarter + recovery for past years. Both are possible.

Question 42

How do I send money from India to France?

Accepted Answer

Two forms stand between you and your money: 15CA (an online declaration you fill) and 15CB (a certificate your CA issues after verifying taxes are paid). Banks won't process outward remittance without the right pair. Rule 37BB: Part A for taxable remittances ≤ ₹5 lakh aggregate per FY, Part B for AO-order-based reductions, Part C for taxable remittances > ₹5L (paired with 15CB), Part D for non-taxable remittances regardless of amount. Pick the wrong part and the bank sends it back. Penalty for wrong filing: ₹1 lakh per form.

Question 43

There's a $1 million limit on NRO transfers. What if my property sale is bigger?

Accepted Answer

RBI caps NRO repatriation at $1 million per financial year. Sold a ₹2+ crore property? You'll need to split the transfer across financial years, or apply for prior RBI approval (takes 2-4 weeks with justification). NRE accounts have no limit, but you can't just move NRO money to NRE. That requires CA certification, tax clearance, and bank compliance approval.

Question 44

My bank transfer is stuck because of a wrong purpose code. What now?

Accepted Answer

Every international transfer from India needs a FEMA purpose code, a specific code telling RBI what the money is for. Investment proceeds, property sale, savings repatriation, each has a different code. Use the wrong one and the bank's compliance team freezes your transfer until corrected. Delays of weeks for a simple mistake. French NRIs deal with this more than they should.

Question 45

I got a tax notice from India. What do French NRIs do?

Accepted Answer

Don't panic, but don't ignore it. 70% of NRI investors got tax notices in 2024, a 340% jump from 2022. India's Project Insight AI now cross-references bank data, investments, and foreign remittances automatically. Common triggers for Indians in Paris: TDS in 26AS with no ITR filed, high-value property transactions, remittances without 15CA/15CB. You have 30 days to respond. If the notice went to your old Indian address and you missed it, the department may have already assessed you with inflated numbers.

Question 46

My Indian bank froze my account for KYC. This is a nightmare.

Accepted Answer

You're not alone. In April 2024, thousands of NRI mutual fund folios were frozen due to SEBI's KYC validation rules. Banks freeze accounts when KYC expires, residential status isn't updated, or when they detect a resident account being used by an NRI. One real case: ₹47 lakh stuck in a frozen IndusInd account. Fix: contact the NRI cell (not the branch), submit updated passport + overseas address proof + PAN. For video KYC, request a slot matching France timezone. Don't deposit into a frozen account, money goes in but can't come out.

Question 47

Why can't my regular CA handle this?

Accepted Answer

Most CAs charge a flat ₹5-15K for NRI ITR filing. DTAA means extra work, treaty verification, TRC coordination, Form 10F, past-year amendments. They earn nothing extra for it. We built TrustNRI for this specific problem. Our fee is success-based, so we earn more when you recover more. Incentives aligned.

Question 48

Do you have CAs who know the France DTAA specifically?

Accepted Answer

Yes. We have CAs who work with French NRIs every day. They know DGFiP (Direction Générale des Finances Publiques), local SIE/SIP's process, the specific treaty articles, and the common mistakes Indians in Paris make. This isn't generic tax filing, it's specialized for people exactly like you.

Question 49

How does pricing work?

Accepted Answer

Free tier: calculator + 26AS scan, no charge ever. Recovery (₹4,999/year + 15% of recovered): full DTAA claim including past years. Concierge (₹14,999/year, no success fee): everything included plus prevention. The success fee only applies when money actually hits your bank account. Zero recovery = zero fee.

Question 50

Is my data safe?

Accepted Answer

26AS processing happens entirely in your browser — the file never touches our servers. For paid services, your data is encrypted and shared only with your assigned CA, who is bound by ICAI confidentiality rules. We follow strict data-handling protocols and DPDP-aligned consent flows. the Indian community in France trusts us with sensitive financial data. We take that seriously.

Régime impatrié, PFU 30%, and the 5% MFN dividend rate that no longer exists.

Where French NRIssave, and where they don't

A typical French NRI's story

How to get your Tax Residency Certificate

Pitfalls we've seen Indians in Paris face

Real people. Real money back.

Everything Indians in Paris ask us

Every year you wait, another €1,320 walks out the door.

Friends & neighbours